Showing posts with label Aston Villa. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Aston Villa. Show all posts
-Jason Kuenle
In economics, the concept of comparative advantage states that the most effective use of limited resources is achieved by maximizing relative advantage over absolute advantage. In soccer, the same concept can be applied to constructing a formation or lineup. The “limited resources” are the ten field players, “advantage” is measured in objective terms by goals or subjective terms by skills such as positioning, passing, dribbling, vision, covering, tackling, etc. Relative advantage is more important than absolute advantage. The goal is to field a side that maximizes the teams’ advantage. For teams fielding Michael Bradley, this presents a tactical problem in some formations; while he has two areas of absolute advantage, their juxtaposition can present issues in creating relative advantage.
- Jason Davis
Michael Bradley's loan move to Aston Villa in the closing hours transfer deadline day was rightly hailed as a step forward for both American players and Bradley himself. There may be some debate as to whether the English Premier League is definitely a better place for Bradley to improve than the Bundesliga, but there's no doubt that his profile will grow at a respected club like Villa in a highly visible league like the Prem.
Michael Bradley's loan move to Aston Villa in the closing hours transfer deadline day was rightly hailed as a step forward for both American players and Bradley himself. There may be some debate as to whether the English Premier League is definitely a better place for Bradley to improve than the Bundesliga, but there's no doubt that his profile will grow at a respected club like Villa in a highly visible league like the Prem.
Twitter has exploded this morning with word that not only has Bob Bradley resigned as US National Team coach, but that he's on his way to becoming Aston Villa's next manager. The former would be big news on its own, but combined with the latter, we're talking super-gigantic-mega story. Bradley as the first American coach in the Premier League is very much this soccer writer's dream come true simply for the fodder.
Unfortunately, the "news" is nothing more than rumor at this juncture. US Soccer hasn't announced Bradley's resignation, Bradley hasn't announced Bradley's resignation, and nothing out of Birmingham indicates Bradley is even on the radar. This explosion of reports in various sources is a house of cards built on one report picked up by English-based outlets. This is the telephone game for the modern age.
The Timeline:
Wednesday-
World Soccer Reader posts a report based on an unnamed source that Bradley will not return as USMNT coach, with a press conference possible as early as this week. (Note that the language in this post has changed at least once, in addition to the "update" posted as some point between Wednesday night and Friday morning.)
Thursday-
WSR's report is twisted through various message boards and Aston Villa blogs.
Today (Friday)-
"Bradley has resigned and will be Villa's next coach" is picked up by talkSport, a national radio station in the UK. TalkSport is known to trade in speculation and rumor, and does not have a strong reputation as a news source. They do not source their story.
Simultaneously or near abouts, the price on Bradley as next manager of Aston Villa tumbles at online betting sites. Pushed by sudden wave of money placed on Bradley, the bookies drop their prices dramatically. Rather than an indication that Bradley is certain to get the job, the price drop is just evidence that the unsubstantiated rumors have led to a rash of betting on Bob.
Other outlets have picked up the talkSport report, sourcing only the talkSport website and noting that no official sources have confirmed the story.
Goal.com has it, referencing "reports."
Big general sports blogs have picked it up, leaning on the Goal.com story.
By now, the sheer breadth of the rumor causes it to go viral through social media and blogs, giving it an air of credibility despite the lack of confirmation. Keep in mind that no mainstream American outlets have picked up the story, and US Soccer vehemently denied Bradley has resigned on Wednesday, and again today.
***
A trail similar to this is responsible for many rumors, so by no means is this situation unique. It's also possible there's a grain of truth in there somewhere, despite the spurious nature of it all; WSR's original report made no claim other than that Bradley would not return for the next cycle. The validity of that report is up to the reader, considering that the source was unnamed. It's literally unprovable until something happens to either confirm (US Soccer announces Bradley's departure) or refute (Bradley's contract is renewed beyond 2010) it.
Until you hear otherwise, this, unfortunately (I'd be happy to see an American coach in the Premier League, at ANY club) is just a rumor.
Then again, I wouldn't be shocked if it's all completely true.
Aston Villa has signed American fullback Eric Lichaj to a three year extension, a good sign that the 21 year old is on the verge of breaking into the first team. That's certainly his goal after going out on loan the past two seasons. What the managerial change at Villa might mean for Lichaj is obviously uncertain; playing time is key for a player of his age, so unless he's solidified his place as a capable squad player who can step in when needed, or reserve games are enough to push him along, perhaps another loan is in the cards.
Aston Villa has committed to seeing his development through, a clear step in the right direction. Lichaj is off of the radar of many American soccer fans simply because he has yet to feature in his clubs first team; while Edgar Castillo (admittedly a natural left back, though I'm told Lichaj can play both sides) gets the hype, a player like Lichaj might end up being the better contributor in the long run.
Lichaj would be worth keeping an eye on this season even without the Villa drama; but with a new boss coming in shortly, Lichaj's fortunes could very well be tied to who it is and how they rate the young American. Lichaj's ability to impress whatever staff aids in the transition is key. I'll go ahead and speculate that the contract extension is an indication that he's done that on some level.
The x-factor in Lichaj's spot on the Villa roster is the new roster rules related to homegrown players. The best guess is that Lichaj does in fact count as homegrown, though that's tied to when he originally signed with the club (which is tough to pin down).
If you haven't already, add Lichaj to your list of Americans in Europe to watch this season; Villa fans I've talked to are high on him, and 2010 could be something of a breakout year.
Editor's Note: Almost as soon as Martin O'Neill quit his post as Aston Villa manager, Bob Bradley's name was mentioned as a possible replacement. In this edition of MFR, our in-house clairvoyant Brian Mechanick takes a peek at how Bob at Villa might go...
By Brian Mechanick
The Board Room, Villa Park, Birmingham.
Randy Lerner: I’d like to thank all the board members for joining us today. It was quite a shock seeing that Northern Irish jackass desert our club, just because I told him all new transfer funds this summer would come from selling whatever leftover drugs he could find in Zat Knight’s old locker.
Anyways, I am proud to announce our new manager is the man who won a Gold Cup, got secondplace in the Confederations Cup, and was able to defeat mighty Algeria in the World Cup, Bob Bradley.
Bob Bradley: [Glares]
Board Member #1: But Mr. Lerner, why Bradley? Martin Jol and Steve McClaren both said they wanted the job!
Randy Lerner: Sorry gents, no more questions. I’m jetting back to sell season tickets in Cleveland. Seriously, since LeBron left those fans are so depressed they’ll buy anything. Our quarterback is Jake Delhomme for Christsakes! But Bob is here to answer all your questions. See you guys same time next year! [Lerner sprints out of the room]
Bob Bradley: Alright men, if there’s one thing I know, it’s winning. And not just on the international level, although my Gold Cup is displayed prominently in my trophy case. I’m a champion on the club level, I won an MLS Cup 12 years ago! Now some changes are coming around here. First issue: Emile Heskey.
Board Member #2: Bloody hell, we know Bob. We’ve been trying to get rid of him for years, but nobody will buy him.
Bob Bradley: WHAT!?!? Get rid of him? We need to build our team around him! Conor Casey single-handedly beat Honduras. Imagine what we can do with a target forward that doesn’t have cinderblocks for feet...!
Board Member #3: [Shaking Head] OK, what else Bob…
Bob Bradley: I’ve been hearing good things about this Agbonlahor kid, is he Generation Adidas?
[Board Members stare in confusion] Come on now, I don’t want to waste a roster spot on a kid who qualifies as a GA. Now I’ve heard this kid is fast. From what Brad Guzan told me, he sounds like a poor man’s Robbie Findley, but we can make do. Speaking of Guzan, he needs to start for this team immediately.
Board Member #1: But we have one of the Premiership’s best keepers in Brad Friedel, why would he replace him?
Bob Bradley: Don’t speak that name! [Turns head and whispers] I asked him once to come backto the USMNT… but he rejected me. I can’t look at him, the hurt is too bad. [A single tear runs down his face].
[Snaps Back] Now I know we have some talented players other teams are after, so who’s trying to get one of our guys?
Board Member #2: Manchester City is pursuing James Milner very intently.
Bob Bradley: Milner? That guy couldn’t even go a half with my boys in the World Cup. Let’s get rid of Jimmy, what do you think we could get for him? I bet if we play hardball we could get a first round pick and two million dollars in allocation money for him.
[Silence]
Board Member #3: Uh Sir, we don’t know what either of those are. But City is offering 20 million pounds for him.
Bob Bradley: 20 million pounds? That’s… [Pulls out calculator with “Gulati” written on back] 31.8 million dollars! Are you guys messing with me?
Sweet Hoddle's mullet, think of all the sweatpants I could buy with that money! I could turn into a walking Nike ad… I could fulfill my lifelong dream of joining Run-DMC!
Board Member #1: Tottenham are after Ashley Young as well. Young wants an improvement over his £65,000 wages to stay.
Bob Bradley: Oh come on, we can afford that, can’t we? I was paying Jorge Campos more than that back in the day. Why don’t we bump him up to what, £80,000 a year?
Board Member #2: Bob, that number wasn’t yearly…
Bob Bradley: A month? Jesus, only a few guys made that back in MLS. Oh well, we can afford a slight raise, can’t we?
Board Member #2: Uh, that was £65,000 a week, Sir.
Bob Bradley: A week! You’ve got to be screwing with me. I could have paid my entire Chivas team, taken them all out on the town, bought a chick a mustache ride from Sacha Kljestan and done blow off of Bianca Klajlich’s ass for that kind of scratch! Young’s gotta go!
Board Member #3: Alright Sir, who should we sign to replace the pair?
Bob Bradley: Is that even a question?!?! We’re signing the best player in the world to come here!
Board Member #1: Lionel Messi?
Board Member #2: Cristiano Ronaldo?
Board Member #3: David Villa?
Bob Bradley: Have you guys been living under a rock? We’re getting my boy Michael! He’s a star, like Pele, Beckenbauer, and Cruyff forged together into 6’2” of skinheaded beauty. I don’t care if you sell Agbonglahor and his three baby mamas to raise the funds, we need Junior! And by the way, he’s the captain now.
Board Member #2: And another player?
Bob Bradley: We’re slow in defense. There’s only one southpaw-footed baller who can right this ship and boss the left. I’m talking Jonny Bornstein.
Board Member #3: Who’s that?
Bob Bradley: Who’s that? Only the greatest Mexican-Jew of all time. The kid gets more panties wet in Honduras than David Suazo advocating civil rights.
Board Member #1: Ok, Bob, how do you plan to set this team up? The 4-4-2 formation you favored with the USA?
Bob Bradley: No, I have a new strategy: a 8-1-1 formation. Clog up the back, have Junior dominate the ball in the middle, and Heskey knock in the goals up top. An unbeatable combo! Now sorry guys, I gotta get out of here. Me and my boy Bruce Springsteen have a date to go rage in Trenton. JERZ FOR LIFE! [Kisses hands then fist-pumps]. See you guys tomorrow, and I better see Junior’s name on the roster or heads will roll here. PEACE!
Board Member #2: It’s going to be a long season.
Just like that, Martin O'Neill resigned from Aston Villa today. "Sudden" doesn't begin to describe this move; with less than a week to go before the start of the Premier League season, Villa will now be scrambling to settle a very unsettled situation.
But we're not here to analyze Villa or mull over the reasons for O'Neill's departure. We're here to note that just as quickly as O'Neill's resignation came down, Bob Bradley was installed as a favorite to replace him. On some levels, it might even make a bit of sense; Villa's owner is American Randy Lerner, US Soccer still has yet to officially re-up Bradley, and Bob plays a system similar to the one the outgoing O'Neill preferred. I dare say that if Bradley wasn't American (okay, American or Canadian), most unbiased observers would see his name and hardly bat an eye.
And I'll be honest: As much as I look forward to the day an American takes over at an English club of note, I'm not on board any Bradley-to-Villa train. The situation portends a poor season no matter who is at the helm; with players headed out but nothing coming in, the club is hardly poised to move up the table. A tumble, especially with managerial drama, seems certain.
No situation will ever be perfect for an American to break the coaching cherry, and I do wonder if just getting the first one out of the way would be for the best. But if Bradley, learning on the job in a league much different than MLS in terms of player acquisition and media scrutiny, failed miserably, wouldn't that just set Americans back? Should Bradley land Villa in the bottom half of the table or worse, how long would it take for another American to get a shot at a job in a top European league?
Of course, now I'm wondering why it even matters if an American coach catches on in England. It's hard to see any immediate benefit for MLS, the National Team, or American soccer in general; over time, coaching abroad might help improve the system as a whole in an ancillary way, but most of the hope for American coaching success is just matter of pride. I root for Americans to succeed in Europe because it improves our standing. It's the same logic I apply to American owners in England; do well because it makes us look better and I'm tired of the dismissive and hostile attitude towards all things Red, White, and Blue.
I suppose those are the same reasons to be fearful of Bradley actually getting the job at Villa; if he screws up, it reflects negatively on American soccer. With an American chairman involved, it's a potential double whammy of reputation-crushing failure.
Bradley's candidacy is simply speculation at this point, so let's not jump the gun. If it becomes a real link, then we can find reasons to worry or be excited. It'll also give me time to figure out on which side I fall. Without a vested interest in how Bradley at Villa might affect the club itself (which I should have, but have yet to truly develop), it's difficult to pin down how I feel about the possibility.
Since I'm waffling uncontrollably, I put it to you: Is Bradley to Villa, should it be a real possibility, a good or bad idea?
The buildup to the English Premier League season, at least in the past few years, always includes a discussion about a potential shakeup in the top four places. Manchester United, Liverpool, Chelsea and Arsenal hold a death grip on those coveted Champions League positions thanks to big time money, and dreams of a change (at least for fans of clubs outside of the Big Four) dance in our heads.
Can Everton really challenge? Is Villa strong enough to last the full season? Will Manchester City's new money leapfrog them over Arsenal?
No matter the chatter, the idea of a top four shakeup continues to be just that, an idea. As Villa proved last year, the squad depth and wherewithal needed to jump ahead of the clubs with the deepest pockets and a track record of success is no mean feat; for every club that "threatens" to breakthrough, there are always hazards and hurdles that make the reality of the jump a near impossible task.
There won't be a shakeup in the top four this year either. At least it doesn't appear that way from where I'm sitting, and as a fan of none of the clubs at the top of the table year in and year out, I have no rooting interest in seeing the domination continue. If fact, I'm desperate for another club to rise into the top tier and end the monotony. It's no fun when the table is so predictable that a full fifth of it can be written out before the season even begins.
Things will change beyond the top four this year, of course, because the clubs below the Champions League spots are not so disparate in talent that a few breaks here and there can't make a massive difference. An injury or two, a fluke goal here and there, perhaps even the emergence of a player not expected to make a massive difference; all those things are likely to affect the standing from fifth to fifteenth.
For the two clubs that threatened the Big Four last year, as well as the one that surprised many by finishing seventh and earning themselves European football, 2009-2010 looks like it may be a significantly different campaign.
Fulham
To be fair, it's not much of a stretch to suppose that Fulham is unlikely to hit the same heights again this year, and they aren't in any way a threat to the top four. A smaller Premier League club with less resources than even their second-tier brethren (and as relegation candidates in previous years, it's probably not accurate to call them "second tier"), Fulham will find themselves seriously tested by competing in both England and Europe. A boon because of the money involved and the attention it brings, the Europa League could be a double-edged sword for the Cottagers. Simply being spread too thin may do them in, resulting in another clubs vaulting themselves in to Fulham's former finish. Ending up mid-table and safe of relegation would be acceptable for them, of course, so the push required for another top seven finish is probably not coming.
Aston Villa
There's much more to say about Aston Villa. The Villans are off to a terrible start, with a difficult test away at Anfield looming tomorrow. Martin O'Neill's sway over his club may be waning, the important John Carew is rumored to be on the outs with the Northern Irishman, and last year's disappointing home form has followed them into this season. That's not a recipe for success, and even a top-half finish might be a struggle. From top four challenger to mid-table also ran is a mighty drop, but fits the reality of Villa's place in the Premier League hierarchy. Having played less matches (as of this writing, they've only played one) than anyone else makes it difficult to assess Villa, but their midweek loss to Rapid Vienna in the Europa League doesn't change the perception that this season might be a comedown.
Everton
If Villa's start has been poor, then Everton's has been disastrous. Thumped at home by Arsenal in the first week of the season, the Toffees today fell pray to the same promoted Burnley team that shocked Manchester United in middweek. Everton has had injury issues and transfer talk distracting them, and hasn't proven that they can play through those concerns. That being said, Everton is the best equipped club in this group to turn things around and finish similarly to the way they did last year; it will David Moyes' best effort, and they desperately need a victory in their next league match against Wigan at Goodison Park they're to have any real chance of repeating their 2008-2009 finish. More than a matter of points, a victory is a matter reversing negative momentum.
Until it actually happens, a the dethroning of any of the Big Four seems like a pipe dream. Anything can happen in sport, and it's certainly possible that this is the year; but if so, someone else is going to have to make a run. Maybe Manchester City actually can sustain their early start with their diamond-encrusted lineup and make a serious run at the Champions League; they may have to be the ones, because the likelihood that last years challengers can seriously push again looks more and more unlikely.
There will be a shakeup, it just won't be the one some many are hoping to see.
As you can see, I continue to spread my wings here, and will be sprinkling in more pieces like this going forward. I'm also hoping to add even more writers, both on American subjects and foreign ones, so if you would like to write for the site, please drop me an email: matchfitusa@gmail.com.
Aston Villa's start hasn't been exactly top-notch. Sixth-place finishers in the Premier League last year, the Birmingham club crashed to earth during a poor second half and limped across the finish line. After starting out with so much promise and appearing poised to make a legitimate run at a Champions League position, Villa instead found themselves ending their season on a sour note.
Unfortunately, that sour flavor permeates Villa's opening effort for this season. After two games played, against arguably inferior opposition, Villa has two defeats and no goals to their credit. Wigan's thrashing of Villa at Villa Park was especially disheartening; O'Neill's club did little right, and though one of Wigan's goals (Hugo Rodallega's wonder strike) was unfortunate, the Birmingham club never showed signs of life. Martin O'Neill stood in his technical area, arms crossed and concern showing, clearly frustrated with his side's effort.
Today was no different. On the road for the away leg of their Europa League series with Rapid Vienna, Villa conceded early (very early, as in first minute early) and never really pushed the Austrians for a leveler. Lost for an answer, O'Neill attempted to change the game with the insertion of Gabriel Abonglahor, but to no avail. Again, O'Neill seemed unable to will his team back to their 2008 form.
The question now becomes, has O'Neill's team quit on him? After last season's crushing collapse, have the Villa players lost faith that their manager can put them in the proper position for success? Today's formation, which left Emile Heskey as the lone striker, certainly could not have inspired confidence.
To be fair, Villa has been without their best upfront target option in John Carew, player whose physical influence at the head of the Villa attack was sorely missed. But one player should not be the difference, and so O'Neill remains on the hook for his club's poor start.
Once confidence is lost in a manager by his charges, it's notoriously difficult, if not impossible, to get back. If Villa's poor form goes on, something they can ill afford, the question of O'Neill's waning influence will become that much easier to answer.
If that is the case, Villa's performance on Monday against Liverpool at Anfield isn't up to snuff, then perhaps Villa's owners are the ones that should be asking the question.
O'Neill covered for his team's shortcomings today in traditional fashion, claiming to be "pleased" with the performance against Rapid Vienna.
"We tried to create and in so doing, when you are getting players forward, obviously you are going to leave gaps but overall I'm pleased."
Those appear to be the words of a man desperately searching for a silver lining. Nothing in today's performance truly instills confidence that Villa is working out the early season kinks, and O'Neill certainly knows that.
"The games are hard and approaching us pretty quickly but when we settle down this season we will be absolutely fine. We need to improve and keep improving. As the whole squad gets wound up and fully fit then we will be OK."
Unfortunately for O'Neill, time is already short. If diagnosed quickly, the ineffective manager might not ruin Villa's season; but if hesitation becomes the order of the day, and O'Neill is left in place to flail madly, things could go very badly very quickly.