- Jason Davis
UEFA chief Michel Platini's baby - a soft salary cap that would require clubs to keep player compensation in proportion with their revenues dubbed "financial fair-play" - is supposed to take effect by the start of the next European season. No one yet knows what the ramifications will be; bigger clubs might not take a hit at all (or could even benefit), while smaller clubs will constantly have to watch the books to ensure they're in compliance. From the fan's perspective, there's some worry the change will mean higher ticket prices. The more a club brings in, the more it can spend. Infusions of cash from a rich owner don't count towards turnover.
Showing posts with label salary cap. Show all posts
Showing posts with label salary cap. Show all posts
- Keith Hickey
In 2011, American domestic soccer is the most secure it has ever been. The league as a whole, and most of its clubs, are in zero danger of collapse. It's hard for us to imagine a time when the very existence of top flight domestic soccer was under threat. But in 1984, that was the case. The halcyon days of Pele and Beckenbauer over, the North American Soccer League was limping into its sixteenth season. Just nine teams remained, down from a high of 24 just four years previous. But as we read in this article from the Sports Illustrated vault, the NASL introduced a revolutionary concept just before its final season:
In 2011, American domestic soccer is the most secure it has ever been. The league as a whole, and most of its clubs, are in zero danger of collapse. It's hard for us to imagine a time when the very existence of top flight domestic soccer was under threat. But in 1984, that was the case. The halcyon days of Pele and Beckenbauer over, the North American Soccer League was limping into its sixteenth season. Just nine teams remained, down from a high of 24 just four years previous. But as we read in this article from the Sports Illustrated vault, the NASL introduced a revolutionary concept just before its final season:
Let me tell you a story…
A long time ago, in a Galaxy far far away…the evil empire (AEG) decided that they needed a marquee signing to increase ticket sales and publicity. As luck would have it, there was a Jedi nearing the end of his lightsabering days who was looking for one more battle to go into. Moreover, this was a Jedi who had actually been heard of by some of the as-yet-unconvinced American sporting public, even though this was perhaps more for because of his wife than for any prowess with said lightsaber. This Jedi’s name was David Beckham, who helped paved the way for other high-profile soccer players to come to the New World.
Per Buzz at the 3rd Degree, Schellas Hyndman let slip at practice today that MLS rosters will expand to 30 next year. This is fairly big news on the back of word that the schedule will be 34 games long (in a 32 week span); the more players teams have to compete with multiple fronts, the better.
Major League Soccer has been out of balance for the last few years. Yes, there's salary cap and roster restriction-mandated parity, a reality that frustrates some even while it guarantees a majority of the league's teams have a chance to win a championship each and every season. And yes, small or non-existent margins mean that many clubs are hesitant to tip the scales for themselves the one way they can, with the designated player rule.
But in the areas of flash and hype, the attention-grabbing, headline-stealing, PR-directed battle for status and awareness, MLS has been tilted dramatically to the West.
The LA Galaxy are a "flagship" MLS franchise because they inhabit the country's second largest market. They have deep-pocketed owners, a first class stadium, and the will to spend money to "grow their brand". This has manifested itself in the signing of one of the world's most visible players in David Beckham and the resulting firestorm of notoriety that followed. In the contest for headlines and mainstream coverage, the Galaxy are winners by a wide margin. No one else in the league, even those few clubs that have signed designated players like Seattle and New York, come close. Add the small detail that the Galaxy have the league's best American player in Landon Donovan, and Los Angeles has garnered the lion's share of interest from the non-soccer segment of the American sports community, the gossip industry, and observers abroad.
Let's consider it a good thing then, that the New York Red Bulls appear on their way to balancing the situation. Finally out of the crumbling, ill-fitting, club-crippling Giants Stadium and settling into Red Bull Arena, New York has all of the prerequisites for an American club looking to make a name for themselves.
Big market? Check.
Owners with deep pockets? Check.
A first-class venue? Check.
And the willingness to spend doesn't seem to be lacking either, with news coming down last week that the Red Bulls plan to buy a third designated player spot as is now allowed by MLS rules. Since New York currently has just one DP in striker Juan Pablo Angel, it's seems safe to assume that they'll be splashing the cash on big name talent as early as this summer.
Perhaps the signings won't bring the club on-field success, though early returns on the Hans Backe/Eric Stover era are positive. That aforementioned parity can be a bitch, excuse the expression, and it will take more than a few aging European stars to bring the Red Bulls their first championship trophy. That hasn't kept the team from making grand pronouncements on their intentions, claiming they can win it all as soon as next year.
The universe, even the American soccer version, needs balance. Attention in all forms is good for a growing league like MLS, and it doesn't matter that the Galaxy and the Red Bulls dominating the headlines by spending more than anyone else is akin to two Darth Vaders doing battle in a maelstrom of footy evil for rest of the country. Perhaps it's not yin and yang, but it does represent progress; the two cities of Los Angeles and New York are connected to one another throughout the history of American sports, and there's no reason that shouldn't be true in soccer. No club should run ahead unchallenged for profile supremacy, and it's about time New York's club took its rightful place as a leading light in Major League Soccer.
Major League Soccer will be better with a New York team acting like a New York team. It looks like that time has finally come.
Sure, it's distasteful when the richest teams get all the attention and outshine teams that "do it right" or are able to win despite a small-market handicap. But villains grow passion in direct opposition; if people love to hate New York (which some already do) the way so many already love to hate LA, that's a massive victory for MLS.
Don Garber is in England, speaking with the creme de la creme of European football, "spreading the gospel" of the business side of American soccer. Garber's focus is financial restraint, cost control, and the glories of salary cap regulation.
I'll pause for a moment while you throw up. Go ahead, I don't mind. I've already gotten my hurling session out of the way.
The cross that American soccer fans bear, and specifically I mean the ones that look past the forced mediocrity that infects Major League Soccer, is the somehow suddenly trendy idea that the salary cap system would be a good idea for uber-rich leagues of soccer-mad Europe. It's almost like being a uncoordinated clutz and having your super-athletic older brother wonder if he might be better off being more like you. It just doesn't wash.
Yet there he is, our esteemed commissioner, standing in front of the leading lights of Europe while they listen intently to his brand of football socialism. I doubt many of them will completely heed the message, since all that money tends to cloud their ability to sense trouble, but he's there's nonetheless. You wonder how many are playing Tetris on their cell phones while The Soccer Don babbles about forcing MLS clubs to spend for their entire rosters what most top league sides spend on one or two teenagers a year.
Maybe some of them are even on Twitter, passing along their immediate reactions to Garber's message to their friends back home in Spain or Italy:
@calcio4ever You have to hear this crazy American talk! All the teams spend the same? Who ever heard of such a thing?
Europe has a problem. Clubs are waist deep and worse in debt, borrowing again and again to continue to finance the important business of winning trophies in the world's biggest game. It's not enough for many of them to simply be, to slot into a place in the pecking order that fits their locality, the size of their fan base, and quality of their academies. Bigger and better is always the order of the day, and when the revenues coming in from tickets, TV deals, and shirt sales don't equal the money going out the door to buy the hottest starlet and pay the elite names, debt piles up. For some, there's incredible pressure to live up to a distant history written when soccer was a different game; once a champion, they just can't imagine themselves sliding back into the pack.
It's not just about money, though that's what's top of mind for European club executives this week. It's also about the competition, or more appropriately, the lack of competition, that pervades the top leagues across the island of Britain and the Continent. If there's anything that the MLS model does well, it's ensure parity; every team has a shot at competing for the title in theory, because no team can seriously outdistance any other due to the salary restrictions they're working under.
Does that make MLS "fairer"? Don Garber seems to think so, and so does Jack Warner; the CONCACAF president believes a salary cap is the way to go in Europe, the better to enable smaller clubs to compete for titles for which they cannot currently compete.
So while many American soccer fans (I said many, not all-keep it in your pants Fake Sigi) are calling for a massive loosening of the belt on this side of the pond, our most important figures are Over There telling the world that they should be more like us. Ouch.
It's not that I have a problem with Garber telling others that the MLS way is good (it has its merits). It's not that I have problem with an American telling Europeans that "our" way is better (we've been doing that for years, so why would we stop now?). It's not even that I don't think Europeans need a bit of a reality check when it comes to their insane spending (they do). No, my problem with all of this, with the speech and the proclaiming the merits of the salary cap system and the backing from Jack Warner (vomit time again) and the fun trio to London is that Garber's presence validates the way MLS does business.
That's it. That's all I care about. Because now, instead of being pushed to at least review their model, to consider that change could be necessary, Garber and the MLS owners sit atop the moral high ground, able to point at Europe and say "See? They're the ones that have it wrong. We're stable and debt free, and things are just plain perfect the way they are."
Stubborn complacency. Not what MLS needs. If the league isn't moving forward, in all arenas including but not limited to its wage system, it's certain to get swallowed up by the American sports morass, left to wither and die. It won't be a giant flame out, ala NASL, but a slower and more painful descent into ultra-irrelevancy.
I draw no conclusions here, nor do I suggest any alternatives to the way that MLS currently governs its balance sheets; I'm still struggling to determine my own views on the salary cap question.
But there's got to be a middle ground, right? A happy medium between the over-commitment that some fear could doom the league and the barrel-scraping pauper's life that it current lives? I mean, Garber didn't take transatlantic flight to tell some of the world's most powerful soccer figures that their leagues should enforce mediocrity, did he?
Don: Two words to control costs, gentlemen. Salary cap.
Euro-execs: That's very nice, but we couldn't help notice that the quality of your league stinks.
Don: Well, yes, that's true. We don't do very well in international competitions, and many American fans turn their backs on us because the quality of play isn't that good. But we have a salary cap, so it's okay.
Euro-execs: You Americans are so weird.
As I recover from a late night of fighting through some technical snafus on the podcast recording, my brain is working just well enough for a thought to occur on the crucial nature of the rest of 2009 for American soccer; several events of note are coming up before the year is out (or in one case, could happen).
While most of us are probably engrossed in the MLS playoff push, tracking the progress of our young Yanks abroad, or looking forward to the rest of World Cup qualifying, a peek to the future, and what is coming, might still be in order.
What: MLB CBA Negotiations
When: Ongoing, with January deadline
Our attention to the ongoing negotiations for the next collective bargaining agreement between MLS and the players tends to wax and wane as events warrant; while we know that they are going on, we're not consistently tracking the story simply because updates are few and far between. Most recently, it was reported that the players are seeking both guaranteed contracts and free agency. Most observers believe the owners have/will balk at both demands, with the latter being a near impossibility.
The shape of the new CBA will be a major determiner in the direction of the league over the life of the contract, with a salary structure, salary limits and minimums, player movement and roster restrictions, etc., all in someway influenced by the agreement. The owners and the league have all of the leverage, but the hope remains that MLS will loosen the purse strings and a push salaries upwards in the interest of growth.
What: MLS Expansion
When: Undetermined, but possible in '09
We know that MLS will expand again, we just don't know when. Montreal appears to be on the fast track, though nothing is guaranteed; renovations to Stade Saputo are dependent on provincial money, and nothing has yet been set in stone. Don Garber continues to make statements regarding the future of the league, often suggesting that MLS needs a team south of Washington, DC. Rumors abound on other expansion possibilities, with St. Louis still talking stadiums, San Antonio getting mentions in the Mexican press, and Ottawa not giving up. No one really knows if MLS will get to twenty teams and remain there for any substantial length of time, or if the league will continue to expand toward 24, 26, or more.
What: World Cup Draw
When: December
The United States still has a bit of work to do to qualify for South Africa 2010, but the remaining schedule and the quality of the squad should see them through. Once qualified, the US will be anxiously awaiting the December World Cup draw in Cape Town; as an unseeded team, the Yanks could, as they did in 2006, find themselves in an extremely difficult group. The draw will help decide the direction of fan expectations leading up to next summer, with a difficult draw sure to elicit hand-wringing and doom-saying and a less daunting one bringing with it predictions of advancement to the knockout round.
The United States' World Cup hopes could literally hinge on the draw, a full seven months before the tournament itself.
Am I missing any other big events that might happen before 2009 is out?

It's all about USA-Mexico this week on Match Fit USA; okay, not so much to start, as Jason and Zach discuss Jozy's move to Hull, MLS in the CCL, and the CBA negotiations before bringing in Brian Zygo to cover USA-Mexico in the second half of the show.
Without a doubt, it's the best show yet.
The Match Fit USA Soccer Show, part of the Champions Soccer Radio Network.
LISTEN in the CSRN media player
DOWNLOAD the show
SUBSCRIBE in iTunes
RSS FEED
Check out Brian's work at Major League Soccer Talk, The Zygo Report and on the radio with "The Orange Slice" a weekly soccer show out of Houston's 1560 The Game.
Note: This is my MLS Daily column for the week, and I expect it will show up there eventually as well. With the USA-Mexico roster coming out, my guess is that the column was bumped for at least a little while. I couldn't deprive you though, and so I leave it to you to read here (oh, but also be sure to visit the excellence that is MLS Daily).
So Kenny Cooper is finally off, gone to make his fortune in the glorious world of European soccer. Bully for him. For most of us, seeing Cooper leave is just about as shocking as discovering that cheap vodka gives you a hangover or that David Beckham wants out of LA (again).
"Inevitable" seems the be the best word to describe it.
Cooper's transfer, to a second division German club, might be the next logical step for his career, and for that (provided you don't have any particular dislike for Kenny) we should be happy. But it's also a disheartening reminder that MLS is still light years away from being able to compete on anything approaching a level playing field with other leagues around the world. Forget top-flights; MLS is clearly second best to Bundesliga 2.
It's hard to blame a young American player for wanting to skip out on MLS when clubs like TSV 1860 Munich are able to double or triple their salaries. It's hard to look at Cooper or anyone in his shoes and say, "Show some loyalty, man! Help grow soccer in the US!"
That ship has clearly sailed, and won't be returning to port until Major League Soccer ups the ante. When you artificially hold down salaries for players that should be the foundation of the league, you shouldn't be too surprised when they leap at the chance to head abroad. Cooper isn't the first, and certainly won't be the last, good young American talent whose future plans will be drawn up without the letters "MLS" appearing anywhere in them.
According to Kenny's father, himself Kenny Cooper, the system is seriously flawed. The league puts too much emphasis and pays too much of a premium to foreign players while underpaying good American ones, in his opinion.
Of course he's right, but it's not as black and white as Herr Cooper would like to make it seem. There's a reason MLS pays foreign players more to ply their trade here: They have to. The reputation of MLS outside (and mostly inside for that matter) of American and Canadian borders isn't exactly stellar; when players consider coming to here to play, it's not the quality of the league or the glory of winning the MLS Cup that draws them.
When your biggest attraction is lifestyle, you're going to have to overpay for mediocre talent. There simply aren't enough good American players to fill rosters, so the importing of players from outside the country is a necessary evil. Foreign players have more options than their American counterparts, generally speaking, and that means that MLS clubs have to pay more to get them here. It also means, because the league can keep down salaries for Americans, they will keep down salaries for Americans. If you spend more than you should have to in one area, trying to save money in another just makes good business sense.
Is it right? Of course not. In a perfect world, Kenny Cooper could get in Dallas what he'll be making in Munich, and good, young, American players would be all over MLS rather than spread across Europe. Names like Tracy, Zizzo, Parkhurst, Goodson, etc., would be gracing teams sheets on this side of the pond, rather than those of lower and secondary league clubs in football-mad Europe. I'd like to think that if MLS could, they would; maybe it's just the realities of running a soccer league in America that has the situation turned around. Still, nothing will change without a serious relaxation in the salary cap and allocation rules, and as far as I can tell, that's not coming anytime soon.
It's an ugly trade off, shorting the players that should be the league's biggest focus so that you can mind every dollar while bringing in foreign players.
Like moths to a flame, American players will continue to flock to Europe by any means necessary. The career of an athlete, especially in the chew-them-up-and-spit-them-out world of soccer, is a short one; cashing in while you can is both imperative and defensible. MLS has more than its share of lesser-talented American players, for whom love of the game and a desire to see the sport succeed in the US seem to be enough. But those players are only loyal to the cause because they have to be; given to option to follow in Kenny Cooper's footsteps and bolt for a European second-division club, they'd do so in a heartbeat, anxious for the opportunity and desperate for the pay raise.
It's the reality of American soccer. What we have is a league full of foreign mercenaries cashing in on marginal talent and frustrated Americans who might prefer to be elsewhere if given the chance.
I suppose using the phrase "necessary evil" (for the second time, sorry about that) gives the league too much of a free pass. From a business standpoint, the salary discongruity might be somewhat understandable; but the situation that Cooper's father laments absolutely sits on the head of MLS, who has chosen to take a ultra-conservative approach to players salaries, creating a system in which teams take on Americans at massive discounts while filling out their rosters with overpaid foreign internationals. Changes are needed desperately, and we can only hope that they are coming.
Until then, and perhaps even afterwards, Americans will continue to be second class citizens in their own domestic league, and continue to look for ways out at every opportunity.
And so we see another American head to the Continent, his head full of dreams and his wallet full of cash.
Auf wiedersehen, Kenny Cooper.
I felt like opining a little tonight, so here's a relatively brief view on the Designated Player rule in MLS, a rule that is up for review after the season and has been a topic of conversation among the owners at this week's All Star Game.
Before I begin, a brief selection from the MLS roster rules:
"The Designated Player Rule allows the League to sign players (under the League's single entity system) whose salary will fall outside of the team salary budget and whose cost above the salary budget charge will be the financial responsibility of the club for which they play. A Designated Player's salary budget charge will be capped at $415,000 per annum in 2009, but his actual compensation is higher. Each team initially received one Designated Player slot, and clubs are allowed to trade Designated Player slots. However, no team can have more than two Designated Players. The Designated Player Rule is a three-year initiative that will conclude after the 2009 MLS season when its future will be reviewed."
That's the DP rule as it currently exists, word for word, directly from the website of Major League Soccer. It sounds nice, doesn't it? Star power sells in America, or so the theory goes, and adding a big name that won't completely cripple a team's ability to assemble players within the constrictions of the salary cap (although it still might) would seem to make a lot of sense.
Only, I'm not buying it.
Soccer is a team game after all, and adding one player, no matter his star status or pedigree, who will still eat up a significant portion of the salary cap (18%), seems to go against the nature of the sport. One player doesn't make a team. The logical conclusion then, is that the although DP rule is intended to raise the quality of MLS through the signing over uber-talented players, that effect will be mitigated by the collection of mediocre talent surrounding those players.
Cliche alert.
You're only as strong as your weakest link.
Perhaps quality isn't really the point; perhaps the DP rule is simply intended to raise the profile of the league through the acquisition of marketable names. The most famous, highest paid, and original DP (you know who) embodies that approach; while the results on the field have been poor, the attention gained, shirts sold, and hype built has made the endeavor worthwhile. Right?
Or not. Too many of those casual fans that gravitated towards the star power of Brand Beckham flitted away rather than stick around and give themselves (and their money) over to MLS. For a moment in time, it seemed worth the imbalance that the DP created. But the league knows, and Don Garber has admitted, that their sales pitch should be aimed at the established soccer fans, not the shallow gawkers; the former have yet to indicate that they'll give their money and time to a league made up of teams with one shining star in constellation of lesser lights.
MLS is facing a dilemma (although I'm not sure they realize it): sell out and throw money at past-their-prime names who will no doubt bring momentary spikes in attention and revenue (tickets sales, shirts, etc.), or buy in and invest in the future of the league, allowing teams to spread more money around, increasing the level of play and hopefully attracting all of those anti-MLS American soccer fans that we know exist.
If it's an either/or situation, I'm fully behind "buy in".
Maybe it's not either/or. Maybe MLS is truly capable of doing both; investing in the overall quality of the league by letting its owners spend more across the board, while also aiming for those big splashes by holding on to the specific dispensation that allows teams to declare one highly-paid player special.
This, we can only hope.
But if I was a betting man - and I'm not (often)- my money would be on DPs, and DPs alone, being the basket where MLS chooses to place all of its egges. Nevermind that many teams are either wary or unconcerned with the rule, believing they have the right plan to produce a winner without a DP or are simply afraid that dumping too much cash on one guy will come back to bite them if things don't go as planned.
DC United and FC Dallas fans, I'll pause for you to curse.
It's unlikely, that have-it-both ways scenario, and I can't shake the feeling even as the Board of Governors (i.e., the owners) prepare to review the DP rule (per both Steve Davis and the MLS rule book), that MLS has its priorities all out of whack. It's one thing to be self-aware, to know that you're not hitting the mark as you should, and to express a genuine understanding of that fact; it's another thing entirely to turn away, reset and refocus, and change your aim.
I realize that half the battle for MLS, its owner/investors, and the fans of the league is getting other people to notice. Designated Players, as long as they are of a certain caliber (and by "caliber" I mean fame rather than ability), are an easy way to drum up interest; but for lack of a better word, Designated Players are an MLS boondoggle.
Just in case you're not familiar with the word:
boon·dog·gle (bōōn'dô'gəl, -dŏg'əl)
n.
An unnecessary or wasteful project or activity.
That's it in a nutshell for me: even on field successes like Guillermo Barros Schelotto represent misplaced priorities on the part of MLS, because they are so rare. Simply put, quality players whose salaries are "reasonable" in world football terms ($750k this season) should be more plentiful in the league. The only way to bring more in is the allow teams greater freedom with their salaries, be it through a direct raising of the cap, or through a soft cap.
We can't expect MLS clubs to become solid talent-evaluators overnight. We can't expect them to wake up tomorrow with the ability to pull good, cheap, talent out of what the greater world has to offer. MLS can't just say "do better" to its clubs and ignore the problem, leaving the league's talent level to stagnate.
Designated Players are a nice shiny toys, ones that MLS owners can show off to all of their friends around the country and the world, as if to say "See? We have high priced talent, too". But they solve nothing in the long run, and only distract from the real problems the league faces. New, soccer-savvy fans aren't going to come running because some American or Canadian club signs a world famous footballer; they'll come running when the game played here begins to resemble the one played half a world away that they watch on their televisions.
The World Football Challenge and other assorted friendlies played the US this summer, featuring some of Europe's most-storied clubs and biggest names, have packed stadiums from coast to coast. Massive crowds of actual soccer fans have been treated to "quality" soccer as the barnstorming teams play out the initial stages of their pre-seasons.
If nothing else, the "Summer of Soccer" has proven that America has strong appetite for the game. The flip side of the Euro-invasion's success is the disheartening evidence that MLS is failing to reach many in this country that already have an ample interest in the sport; it's not the unconverted, non-soccer sports fan that the league must attract to reach new heights, but that footy-obsessed Eurosnob that refuses to acknowledge the domestic competition as an outlet for their passion.
It's not an easy sell. The uber-rich, super-talented footballers that line up for Chelsea, AC Milan, Inter Milan, etc. are infinitely more glamorous and attractive than the under-paid, workman-like players that populate Major League Soccer. MLS clubs lack the history and pomp of those century-old European clubs, and the American-style nicknames and wacky color schemes set them widely apart as professional soccer teams.
If Major League Soccer wants to be relevant, if they have any designs on attracting at least a few of those fans that willingly plunked down their hard-earned money to see foreign teams play, they're going to have to make a few changes. What changes might be needed, and how best to implement them are the million dollar questions; it's not something to be taken lightly, no matter how "obvious" the steps might seem to those of us on the outside.
Neither are they overnight, quick-fixes. It will continue to take time for MLS to infiltrate the existing soccer fan base in the US, as it's likely to be a slow and arduous process simply because it has to be. Still, the league must take the first baby steps to even give itself a chance, and must do it soon or risk missing out on the soccer "boom" we seem to be witnessing.
Here's the rundown: The list of issues that continue to face the league, the ones most talked about in fan and blogger circles, and the ones that have been trodden over so many times that I'm clearly being redundant.
Salaries
CBA negotiations have begun, the players and the league are meeting, and the hope is that there is some progress being made. For me, the salary issue isn't one of "fair" compensation or the ability to acquire quality alone (i.e., salary cap); it's also a matter of perception. As long as the low end of MLS salaries, as well as those of the mid-level talent that make up the bulk of league starters, sits below the six figure mark, MLS will be viewed as a poor league populated by "semi-pro" type talent, especially when juxtaposed the millionaires that line up for top-level clubs in leagues easily available to American soccer fans via television. The gap will (and should) remain massive for the foreseeable future and beyond, and many will still discount MLS players because they make a pittance compared to the Lampards and Terrys of the world; but if the league can find a way to pay the bulk of their talent a wage that at least allows them to live without roommates, it will be a giant step towards respectibility.
Scheduling
The league continues to hold on to their excuse that playing through international breaks is a financial necessity; many fans don't buy it, or if they do, want MLS to put the league on hold anyway. Even as I make allowances and take Garber's pleas of poverty (figurative, of course) at face value, I still believe that the growth of MLS as a quality soccer product is being stunted by the refusal to address the issue. Choosing a few dates a season to work around, while playing through others, seems like a reasonable compromise. While no one would be entirely happy, it would be a clear sign that MLS wants to operate within the framework of the greater footballing world. Eurosnobs and their kin will continue to point in derision at MLS for as long as the league holds out.
Atmosphere
I'm of the solidly held opinion that the lack of consistent atmosphere is one of the biggest turn-offs for fans who naturally look to Europe for their football fix; for every massive Seattle and Toronto crowd, there's minuscule attendance in other cities that adds nothing to the excitement of the game. The leagues most easily available to soccer fans in the US - England, Spain, Italy, and Germany - all have atmospheres that ramp up the electricity, tension, and appeal with large, engaged crowds. Combined with the obvious talent gap, and MLS becomes unwatchable for many. THe supporter culture is growing in US, but too often MLS clubs find themselves at odds with the people they need most, hindering the effect those groups might have both the live and televised experience. Marketing and club-supporter cooperation are the most obvious areas in need of improvement and should make a marked difference if given the proper attention; but "atmosphere" is the least controllable variable for MLS, and may be the slowest to change in a positive manner.
It's been quite the summer for fans of the game in the United States. Whether you're a fan of European (and Mexican; can't forget about Club America) football, MLS, or both, big foreign clubs gracing our shores is truly a sight to behold. If MLS looks worse by comparison because those teams came here, then the goal should be to acknowledged those problems as the spotlight is intensified, and work towards fixing them.
It's on MLS to make the changes, though, and they haven't exactly inspired much confidence with their track record; a full reversal may not be in the offing, but even small one would be heartening.
If MLS wants to eventually draw the type of excitement, be it in ten, twenty, or thirty years, that we've seen during this friendly period (which has yet to end), then they must take the events of this summer to heart.
Change is good.
Two issues, somewhat related, that I felt like expounding upon a bit today. The business of MLS is almost as important as the play on the field , and interests a lot of us (though I don't blame you if you don't care).
CBA Negotiations Opened "Recently" According to Garber
According to a Sports Business Journal report that I cannot link to because that site is subscription only (thanks to Jamie Trecker on Twitter for the heads up), MLS commissioner Don Garber has said that management has only recently opened negotiations with the players union on the new collective bargaining agreement.
The current CBA expires at the end of January 2010.
While the logical part of me understands that "make them sweat" is a solid negotiating tactic on the part of the league, especially in the current economic environment, I can't help be be a little disappointed. MLS has enough of a struggle ahead of it without any labor issues cropping up and ruining whatever momentum there may be. I had hoped "good faith" would trump "good business" in this situation, and that both sides would come to the table anxious to work out a deal that benefits everyone.
I tend to lean towards the players in this situation, generally because the numbers at the low end of the pay-scale are so ridiculous, and maybe that's coloring my reaction. The owners, as business men, absolutely have the right to pursue whatever course of action they believe will end with them getting a favorable agreement; but soccer in the US is not strong enough to handle a pure get-the-best-deal-you-can negotiation. That doesn't mean that the league should roll over, just that they must recognize that this CBA isn't just about business. It's also about projecting an image of MLS and proving to the fans that things are moving in the right direction (meaning salaries are going up, because we relate salaries to quality whether that's true or not).
Let's hope, despite the "late" start, that things go smoothly and that MLS works out a deal beneficial to the players yet capable of sustaining the league as a business.
The DP Rule Under the Microscope
Avoiding the Drop has a nice review of the Designated Player rule, one that has me wondering about the last line of the text as it is written in the MLS rulebook:
The Designated Player Rule allows the League to sign players (under the League’s single entity system) whose salary will fall outside of the team salary budget and whose cost above the salary budget charge will be the financial responsibility of the club for which they play. A Designated Player’s salary budget charge will be capped at $415,000 per annum in 2009, but his actual compensation is higher. Each team initially received one Designated Player slot, and clubs are allowed to trade Designated Player slots. However, no team can have more than two Designated Players. The Designated Player Rule is a three-year initiative that will conclude after the 2009 MLS season when its future will be reviewed.
Perhaps I'm alone, but I don't think I knew the rule would come up for review after this season. That may be due, in part (or in total), to the CBA expiring; reviewing the rule makes sense if you're not yet sure what the salary pool for non-DP players will be.
So is there any chance they'll repeal it? Doubtful. It would be awfully sticky to back out of those DP deals that already exists, and grandfathering them would only penalize teams that don't currently have DPs. Whether they actually would sign one is immaterial; the inability to do so wouldn't be fair, and we know that MLS is all about what's fair and creates parity.
I wouldn't care if they did repeal the rule and grandfather in the six contracts that exist, but I'm not MLS.
The only legitimate way to change the DP rule without creating a mess (again, it's doubtful they will) is to institute the "soft cap" for which some have lobbied. With the soft cap set at a predertermined salary pool contribution, and then augmented by an additional amount the clubs could spend out of their own pockets, nothing would need to change. The DP rule would go away, teams would have more freedom to sign players, and everyone would be happy.
Or at least I would.

Here's an unfortunate (depending on your viewpoint) fact: the Major League Soccer salary cap isn't going anywhere. Even a significant increase in the cap seems unlikely for the foreseeable future, as the league struggles to raise its profile and bring in more television dollars. The prevailing financial prudence means that many fans will continue to be frustrated with the minuscule amount of money their teams are permitted to spend on players. This is especially true for fans of clubs that have the wherewithal to go well beyond the cap; profitable teams with strong attendance continue to be handcuffed by restrictions meant to ensure the solvency of the league, as well as maintain competitive parity.
There seems to be a reasonable answer to the problem, though. A way to allow those clubs with larger coffers to flex their muscle without out-pacing the rest of the league so much that it creates a competitive imbalance. It's called a "soft" cap.
I became aware of the soft cap concept thanks to Ben Knight from It's Called Football and Onward Soccer, who mentioned it on ICF; Ben also wrote an ebullient response to the idea, which was originally proposed by Richard Snowden of Soccer365 back in December. Richard's numbers are a little higher than I might suggest, as I would argue that something equivalent to what Duane Rollins (24th Minute) suggested in the comments of my recent post on parity makes more sense.
Take the cap as it exists, the money for which comes from the central player salary pool, and tack on an additional amount (again, Duane's $2.5 million makes sense) which owners can spend out of their own pockets to upgrade their teams. While some owners would obviously pass, it would allow those who wish to an opportunity to separate themselves from the pack. Keep the exempted amount low enough, and the league stays competitive from top to bottom, but separates things just enough to provide some haves v. havenots intrigue.
Essentially, the idea is the DP rule spread over multiple players, and capped. Imagine how much better off LA would be if half of Beckham's salary went towards the contracts of five players rather than one.
Most of what can be said on the subject already has, so I'll defer to Misters Knight and Snowden. If MLS is going to take the next step into international relevancy (both on the open player market as well as in international competitions), something needs to change to allow clubs more freedom to sign talent. A soft cap seems the most logical way to effect change without risking overspending or the league's bottom line.
Thoughts?
Tonight in Mexico, the Montreal Impact have a chance to join their league-mates, the Puerto Rico Islanders, in the semi-finals of the CONCACAF Champions League. Montreal heads to Estadio Corona with a 2-0 lead in the series, after their spectacularly attended triumph in Quebec last week.
With ninety minutes of resolute defending, Montreal can deliver the second blow of a two punch combination to the already fragile repuatation of MLS in the timespan of twenty-four hours. Already smarting from the crashing exit of the Dynamo, their lone remaining club in the competition, the league must now deal with the unwanted comparison that inevitably come when teams from a "lesser" league progress farther than those from the FIFA sanctioned U.S. First Division.
Supporters of MLS are apoplectic, supporters of USL (and specifically Montreal and Puerto Rico) are crowing, and the top dogs of MLS are....?
It's impossible to tell if MLS views anything transpiring in the CCL as damaging to their standing in the greater international soccer community. Perhaps the league is content to focus on its domestic competition, its artficially inflated interleague cup competition (SuperLiga), and the current efforts to rapidly expand.
Expansion is fun. New teams, new colors, new kits, and new stadiums (for the most part), all bring excitement, giving MLS a touch of glamour every time a new franchise is announced. While most fans are hypnotized by expansion and its accompanying accoutrement, some have questioned the policy of growth. Instead, they argue, the league should consolidate its current base, working towards a better on-field product that could better compete on the international stage.
The success of two teams in a league nominally inferior to MLS should be a wake up call to those invested in MLS and its future. The standard excuses are beginning to wear thin, and supporters of the league are beyond the point of frustration. MLS needs to find a way, and quickly, to balance their expansion aspirations against the obvious need to expand overall player quality. If American clubs are to make to mark against their CONCACAF competitors, something must be done to level the playing field. A relaxed or drastically increased salary cap, roster exceptions for teams in outside competitions, or some other creative measure needs to be instituted, and instituted now.
For every year that the CONCACAF Champions League ends without an MLS representative in the final (or as champion), and for every year one (or more) USL team progresses farther than their "major league" competition, MLS takes another step back towards soccer irrelevancy.
With ninety minutes of resolute defending, Montreal can deliver the second blow of a two punch combination to the already fragile repuatation of MLS in the timespan of twenty-four hours. Already smarting from the crashing exit of the Dynamo, their lone remaining club in the competition, the league must now deal with the unwanted comparison that inevitably come when teams from a "lesser" league progress farther than those from the FIFA sanctioned U.S. First Division.
Supporters of MLS are apoplectic, supporters of USL (and specifically Montreal and Puerto Rico) are crowing, and the top dogs of MLS are....?
It's impossible to tell if MLS views anything transpiring in the CCL as damaging to their standing in the greater international soccer community. Perhaps the league is content to focus on its domestic competition, its artficially inflated interleague cup competition (SuperLiga), and the current efforts to rapidly expand.
Expansion is fun. New teams, new colors, new kits, and new stadiums (for the most part), all bring excitement, giving MLS a touch of glamour every time a new franchise is announced. While most fans are hypnotized by expansion and its accompanying accoutrement, some have questioned the policy of growth. Instead, they argue, the league should consolidate its current base, working towards a better on-field product that could better compete on the international stage.
The success of two teams in a league nominally inferior to MLS should be a wake up call to those invested in MLS and its future. The standard excuses are beginning to wear thin, and supporters of the league are beyond the point of frustration. MLS needs to find a way, and quickly, to balance their expansion aspirations against the obvious need to expand overall player quality. If American clubs are to make to mark against their CONCACAF competitors, something must be done to level the playing field. A relaxed or drastically increased salary cap, roster exceptions for teams in outside competitions, or some other creative measure needs to be instituted, and instituted now.
For every year that the CONCACAF Champions League ends without an MLS representative in the final (or as champion), and for every year one (or more) USL team progresses farther than their "major league" competition, MLS takes another step back towards soccer irrelevancy.