- Keith Hickey (With special thanks to Ray Escamilla)
The MLS Players' Union released the salaries for all of their members (every player in Major League Soccer) today. I sifted through the raw data to bring you the most interesting nuggets of information. All figures use the "guaranteed compensation" statistics.
Showing posts with label salaries. Show all posts
Showing posts with label salaries. Show all posts

Prairie Rose and Jimmy Conrad
While soccer is ever-increasing in popularity in the United States, the traditional game of record, and the one that holds an equivalent place in the cultural identity of the country as "football" does in England, is baseball.
Whether you love it or hate it, it's hard to argue that the history of professional baseball is not over-romanticized; everything was better "back when" (never mind that little problem of latent racism). Times were simpler, the money was smaller, the games meant more, and the players were just doing a job that happened to invoke the passionate fandom of their communities. The passage of time, the lack of widespread television coverage, and the biased judgments of those who were there are all elements in these "Golden Age" characterizations.
One romanticized notion that I've heard throughout my life, particularly in relation to old-time baseball's most romanticized team, the Brooklyn Dodgers, was that baseball was better when the players were approachable, neighborhood guys. Until the big money of the modern age, baseball players lived in the communities in which they played; for Dodgers fans, part of the love they had for their team came from that "regular guy" status the players carried.
As an example, here is an excerpt from the transcript of an NPR piece titled "When 'Next Year' Arrived for Dodger Fans":
Mr. BEN CARRAGIE (Brooklyn, New York, Resident): "Pee Wee lived on 97th, and my aunt owned a liquor store, and he used to come out. A couple of Sundays I used to go and see him--I was about 10 or 11 years old--and he'd say hello to you, you know? He'd wave over when he was going downstairs. The Dodgers were family because they lived in Brooklyn. You know, we loved them dearly."
This type of situation happened all over the country in the first and middle part of the century. My own great-uncle used to tell stories of going to the movies with Philadelphia A's slugger Jimmie Foxx in the 1930s. These players were common folk with famous jobs, not untouchable mega-stars living sheltered lives.
I'm almost certain, without looking for sources, that English football has similar stories from their own "Golden Age", when the game was working class and local.
Money and media have changed all that. In the modern world, money has come to represent value, and not just in financial terms. It seems clear that MLS gets less respect because its players are "underpaid" by modern sports standards; for some American soccer fans, the extreme disparity between the salaries of Europe's biggest stars and the those in MLS makes the domestic league immediately less attractive. For the average American sports fan, for whom soccer is not entirely distasteful, the same applies; how can Major League Soccer be any good when the money its players make is almost nothing compared to the astronomical wages being paid in the NFL, NBA, and Major League Baseball?
It's unfortunate really, especially because MLS players are generally approachable, generally accessible, and generally willing to interact with their fans in ways that athletes from America's biggest sports never would. Passionate MLS fans know this from personal experience; there are fans across the country who wouldn't be out of line calling certain local players their "friends".
Not everyone wishes for days gone by when professional athletes were just regular joes, guys who if you said hello to them walking down the street they'd stop and shake your hand. For some, the riches and exalted status that accompanies big time sports fame is preferable to our heroes being too much like us. But MLS is different, and embodies a culture at odds with the modern sports world; while Alex Rodriguez is chased by paparazzi and protected by hired muscle, America's best soccer players are barely noticed, left to go about their daily lives as so many of us do.
But that also makes them unique. Would Major League Soccer be better off with "overpaid" stars, multimillionaire journeymen, and an average salary closer to seven figures than five? Probably. It would certainly help with the league's credibility, and would help to draw more attention from a resistant majority. Certainly something would be lost, though, and I wonder if MLS fans would actually be better off if their league and the players in it was no longer a unique collection of regular guys but a monstrous cash-rich behemoth like so many other leagues.
Perhaps it's best to make no judgments; what's different, and idealized by some, isn't always better. Like Brooklyn and its Dodgers in the 1950s, MLS and its fans in the 21st Century are likely living through an evolutionary phase that will fade away with time.
Besides, things aren't exactly comparable; our age is more transient, more spread out, and less provincial than ever before. Where Flatbush was an insular community in which the Dodger players both lived and worked and their fans might see them grocery shopping, MLS communities are more concept than reality. The digital age has created a different type of community, one that involves immediate communication across vast distances.

Stuart Holden and fan, from his Twitter feed
Twitter, Facebook, blogs, etc., have become our virtual Flatbush, where MLS players (who you still might see out somewhere) are available for a chat to discuss the news of the day or greater soccer world. In the words of Prairie Rose Clayton, American soccer's most famous banner-making superfan:
"American soccer's a well-networked community, and there's a pretty good case to be made that the internet is our neighborhood. It's also no great secret that every single thing the fans joke, gossip, and complain about, the players do, too, as illustrated by any given player who's ever written a blog, particularly one where he talks to his coworkers--Jimmy Conrad, I'm looking in your direction.
So, say, you follow most of the MLS and/or yank abroad guys on twitter, you get to see Twellman complaining about whatever's on SportsCenter that afternoon, or Andy Williams talking about his wife's fight with cancer right after he's just been talking smack to Esky about a video game. Edu, Jozy, and Beas are spending their days off making yo mama so fat jokes at one another. Joe Cannon laments about not getting a date, Brad Knighton's stuck in traffic on I-95, Kei Kamara's eating burritos and watching Heroes. You log into Facebook and get to see Holden or Feilhaber posting questionable party photos just like any other 20something. You wish some player a happy birthday, and he thanks you, even if he may not know you in real life. You start peppering them with stupid questions, they reply with stupid answers. They're all doing the same stuff as us jerks in the cheap seats."
Would all of that disappear if salaries grew and players become more like their big time sports contemporaries? I honestly don't know. Perhaps this is a soccer thing more than a money thing. Maybe we'll always have players who can relate to the fans. Maybe not.
If it's not a soccer thing, and one day we do have megastars populating our domestic soccer league, separated from their fans by money and fame, I'm guessing we'll look back on these halcyon days and romanticize them, just as all of those baseball historians like to do.
Disheartening news on the ongoing collective bargaining negotiations between Major League Soccer and the MLS Players Union today; the league's proposal last week has the players threatening to strike if it is not improved considerably.
The league has rejected the players push for guaranteed contracts, as well as an elimination of club option clauses currently included in MLS contracts. The former is mentioned regularly as a focus of the players, though it runs counter to most player contracts around the world, while the former is viewed by the players as being in violation of FIFA regulations.
Though the league has proposed a salary cap increase, the players have labelled it a "joke". The cap would increase in single-digit percentage increments in the league's proposal, a disappointing response that seems ridiculous in light of successes gained in recent years.
Workers compensation is another sticky issue, with the league pushing to recoup expenses paid for player injuries if that player receives a workers comp award.
As frustrating as this news is, and as ridiculous as a players strike sounds, remember that negotiations are still in the game-of-chicken phase. I harbored worries that the league would over play their hand, and push for restrictive and overly-restrictive financial terms, fears today's update has done nothing to ease. The union is maintaining that a strike is in play partly because many of the league's players can simply find jobs with equal pay; the minuscule salaries paid on the low end of the MLS scale give them a "nothing to lose" attitude.
A strike would be catastrophic to top-flight professional soccer in the United States, and both sides need to keep that in mind. The current CBA expires January 31st; I expect them to get much closer over the course of the next two and half months, but there will likely be one or two issues that will determine if an agreement is reached before that deadline. Let's hope the owners and the union can reach common ground.
Portland's MLS expansion wobbles along, with stadium financing taking shape (we hope), a marketing campaign already in place, and the typical community-resistance and tired questions over Major League Soccer's viability all along for the ride.
It's that last tag-along that sticks in the craw of many fans; if there's anything that Major League Soccer has done right in its fourteen years of existence, it's ensuring that it won't be going away due to financial instability. It's been a long, penny-pinching road to get to this point, and while "success" for the league is in the eye of the beholder, few that really understand the landscape, how the league operates, and the lengths to which the leadership has gone to maintain a solid footing, believe it's likely to fold.
Still there is skepticism in Portland, despite the city's rich soccer history. The Oregon Economics Blog points out the parallels with Portland's gaining of an NBA team back in 1970; amazingly enough, professional basketball was less of a sure thing than MLS might be. It's taken for granted now that the NBA was always a success; but time has a way skewing our perception, and with professional basketball becoming big business over the last thirty years, those less-than-big-time days are forgotten about.
It's forty years later Portland still has the Blazers, a team that has become a significant part of their civic identity. Is there really any reason to believe that the Timbers will be any different?
- Speaking of financial instability and overspending, the MLS pragmatists need only point Down Under for an example of where league could be if the powers that be aren't careful. Australia's A-League is struggling with red ink, declining attendance, and a tough decision between slow-growth and rapid expansion. Sound familiar? The parallels between the A-League and MLS may be overblown just a bit, but there's probably a lesson in there somewhere. Australia is bidding, just as the U.S. is, for the 2018 or 2022 World Cup, something that gets some of the blame for the A-League's lack of direction. The one parallel that doesn't exist is who controls the league; the Aussie FA runs the club competition there, a setup many American soccer fans would cringe to conceive of here.
- MLS players are (generally) underpaid, a situation that most observers and fans rightfully lament. But the opposite viewpoint is that American players are the opposite of "spoiled", a condition often applied to players in other parts of the world. A Polish site has taken a look at the difference between "spoiled" Polish players and those in Major League Soccer, using the latter to criticize the former (this was passed through Google translate, so I apologize for the difficult read); most interesting is the implication that here it's about winning, while there it's about money. I'm not sure that makes players here more virtuous, necessarily (some of them have little choice about where to play), but it does put our little league into perspective. Most galling for the Polish writer is the thought that the Americans, many of whom play in MLS, will be competing for the World Cup next year while those pampered Polish stars sit home.
The condition of professional soccer in the United States is such that the when presented with a choice between playing the game on its highest level here or hanging up the boots and focusing on a job in the "real world" is not as simple as it should be.
For millions of young athletes in America, the dream of a professional career rises above and surpasses any other; it's true for baseball, American football, basketball, and hockey. To reach the pinnacle of those sports and have a chance to play on big stages in front of thousands of people all the while getting paid (very well) to do so is a hard proposition to pass up. But soccer doesn't fit that dream path, both because the game is an afterthought at best in the US, and because player salaries lag miles behind those in major American sports leagues.
Three college soccer players are faced with the dilemma, and the Indiana Daily Student describes their struggle; stick it out and become professional footballers, or pass on what will probably be a hard-scrabble existence to follow the alternate dream of becoming a doctor. Here's to the hope that one day, their choice won't be so difficult.
- From the capital city of New York comes a remembrance of the New York Eagles, Albany's American Soccer League representative way back in 1979. Interesting notes from this piece include the national makeup of the Eagles' squad, the internal conflict that occurred because of it, and the absolute reverence that the author holds for the scoring hero of the team, Billy Boljevic. With the history of American soccer being littered with failed teams and short-lived clubs, there are bound to be thousands of stories like this one. Let's hope thirty years from now, people are remembering the 2009 season for teams that are still alive and thriving.
- Here's peek at one fan's experience this summer, and the stressful nature of being a US National Team supporter in a country where you're simply bound to be outnumbered by supporters of the opposition when attending a match. Even as more Americans pick up the game and become fans of the national team, there's not likely to be a break in the live supporter numbers any time soon. Immigrants, especially those from Latin America, are simply more rabid about their support in much greater numbers than Americans; this means that although there might be enough Yank fans to at least equal the number of "away" supporters, they simply don't snap up tickets as quickly.
Deep Cuts appears daily and is an attempt to bring you soccer links from off the beaten path or of particular interest. If you come across something you think would make a good Deep Cut, please send it along to matchfitusa@gmail.com.
As I recover from a late night of fighting through some technical snafus on the podcast recording, my brain is working just well enough for a thought to occur on the crucial nature of the rest of 2009 for American soccer; several events of note are coming up before the year is out (or in one case, could happen).
While most of us are probably engrossed in the MLS playoff push, tracking the progress of our young Yanks abroad, or looking forward to the rest of World Cup qualifying, a peek to the future, and what is coming, might still be in order.
What: MLB CBA Negotiations
When: Ongoing, with January deadline
Our attention to the ongoing negotiations for the next collective bargaining agreement between MLS and the players tends to wax and wane as events warrant; while we know that they are going on, we're not consistently tracking the story simply because updates are few and far between. Most recently, it was reported that the players are seeking both guaranteed contracts and free agency. Most observers believe the owners have/will balk at both demands, with the latter being a near impossibility.
The shape of the new CBA will be a major determiner in the direction of the league over the life of the contract, with a salary structure, salary limits and minimums, player movement and roster restrictions, etc., all in someway influenced by the agreement. The owners and the league have all of the leverage, but the hope remains that MLS will loosen the purse strings and a push salaries upwards in the interest of growth.
What: MLS Expansion
When: Undetermined, but possible in '09
We know that MLS will expand again, we just don't know when. Montreal appears to be on the fast track, though nothing is guaranteed; renovations to Stade Saputo are dependent on provincial money, and nothing has yet been set in stone. Don Garber continues to make statements regarding the future of the league, often suggesting that MLS needs a team south of Washington, DC. Rumors abound on other expansion possibilities, with St. Louis still talking stadiums, San Antonio getting mentions in the Mexican press, and Ottawa not giving up. No one really knows if MLS will get to twenty teams and remain there for any substantial length of time, or if the league will continue to expand toward 24, 26, or more.
What: World Cup Draw
When: December
The United States still has a bit of work to do to qualify for South Africa 2010, but the remaining schedule and the quality of the squad should see them through. Once qualified, the US will be anxiously awaiting the December World Cup draw in Cape Town; as an unseeded team, the Yanks could, as they did in 2006, find themselves in an extremely difficult group. The draw will help decide the direction of fan expectations leading up to next summer, with a difficult draw sure to elicit hand-wringing and doom-saying and a less daunting one bringing with it predictions of advancement to the knockout round.
The United States' World Cup hopes could literally hinge on the draw, a full seven months before the tournament itself.
Am I missing any other big events that might happen before 2009 is out?
Sports Business Journal reports that the CBA negotiations between the MLS Players Union and the league have taken an interesting turn: in addition to guaranteed contracts (currently contracts don't become guaranteed until a certain point in the season), the players are said to be asking for free agency.
This would constitute a fundamental change in the way that Major League Soccer conducts their business; with the single-entity structure, all contracts are negotiated by the league and players can be assigned to any team at the discretion of MLS. Free agency is something the league is afraid of, as it has the potential to result in skyrocketing salaries as clubs vie for a player's services.
The "single-entity" structure goes well beyond how the league contracts players, of course, including the collection of revenue and how that money might be dispersed among the franchises. Outside of the money above $400k that hits the salary cap for a Designated Player, all salaries are paid out of a central salary pool dictated by the league and the CBA. Free agency wouldn't seem to fit the model. In that system, each team must be allowed to negotiate contracts without worrying about league approval, something that seems unlikely to change.
MLS has rightly watched every penny since their launch in 1995, something which has given the league viability and longevity despite the second-class nature of the sport in the United States (and now Canada). For the league to reverse themselves at this juncture, just when they appear to have leverage in the marketplace with expansion clubs coming, would be counterproductive.
My sense is that the players union feels it necessary to bring up free agency whether it's actually a possibility or not. They are, after all, and advocacy organization whose ultimate goal is to get the players the best possible deal; free agency would certainly be that, as the current system artificially depresses salaries and keeps players from playing where they'd like to. The system is the sticking point, but we can hardly fault the Union of asking; it's their job.
That being said, MLS will not be going to free agency anytime soon. The owners can rightly argue that it's exactly single-entity and central contract ownership that has allowed the league to reach this point; to change it now would be folly, a step away from financial responsibility that would have more than a few of us wondering if MLS truly is headed down the NASL path.