Showing posts with label college soccer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label college soccer. Show all posts

Machines, of the Hype and Fax Variety

Wednesday, February 02, 2011 | View Comments
- Jason Davis

Here are two things I've decided to jam together for no other reason than that they're not substantial enough for two posts, and they allow for the somewhat clever headline.


This deserves more in-depth treatment, but alas, there is no time. Craig Stouffer has the lowdown on an NCAA rule change that is a massive coup for MLS; simply put, players will no longer jeopardize their eligibility if they simply play alongside professionals. Yes, if you weren't aware, that was the old rule, as asinine as it sounds.


If, and it's looking fairly certain from what most in-the-know are saying, the reserve league comes back, MLS academy prospects can now play in those matches without losing their college eligibility. The opportunity to test academy kids against stronger opposition will ultimately be invaluable to clubs as they look to flesh out who's ready for the first team and who's not.


College soccer isn't going anywhere; this rule change lets kids who aren't ready for MLS at 18 move on to the college game with a chance to get an education. If they're good enough for the league when their college time is over, the MLS club can always bring them back. New rule, new options.


Again, in terms of the league's ability to bring along young players through competition against professionals and better identify the best prospects in which to invest first-team contracts, the benefit of this rule change cannot be overstated.


Unfortunately, the rule change didn't come about specifically due to soccer. That fact gives us little hope college soccer's on-field rules will be brought in line with FIFA rules anytime soon.




Jimmy Conrad

Scan the American soccer blogosphere any given week and you're likely to come across something that hits on at least one of the following topics:

Promotion/Relegation

Youth Development

Signing/Finding Talent


Sometimes, the pieces written on these subjects are intelligent, well-reasoned, and unique. More often than not, however, they're none of the above; predominantly, they're shallow, naive, simplistic, and ignore serious problems with the approaches they present.


Although not a blogger in the usual sense, Jimmy Conrad has decided to weigh in with his own thoughts on each of the above mentioned topics. It's the question everyone wants to ask, and so many think they might have the answer to: How do we, the American soccer community, take the game to the next level in this country?


Jimmy's first suggestion, a two-tiered MLS that includes promotion and relegation, goes nowhere unique, even if it is a reasonable approach to the "problem". But Conrad, who says twenty MLS teams could be divided into two leagues of ten, glosses over that tricky issue of forcing certain teams to start in the second division, using arbitrary criteria and exceptions to determine the split of first level and second level clubs.


Where Conrad has struck a chord was with his second two suggestions, both related directly to player development; unfortunately though, the prerequisite action, having MLS become a "monopoly" by buying up every professional American soccer league (including indoor), is so large a leap for MLS that it makes me cringe to read it. Why would an organization that imposes strict budgetary control and limits costs in every way possible step up and make such a large financial commitment? The league's owners may have deep pockets individually, but they have shown that as a collective group frugality wins out over all else. The move makes sense as a way to gain control and restructure an American soccer pyramid that has entirely too many cooks in the kitchen at the moment, but it would also be incredibly expensive. It's tantalizingly visionary, but depressingly impossible.


Delving into Conrad's thoughts on what to do with those lower division and indoor leagues once they're under the MLS umbrella seems pointless because it's so unlikely, but he does make solid suggestions for how to help young players gain crucial experience. Most unique is his thought on having young MLS player under a certain threshold of playing time in the outdoor season (he set this as 1,000 minutes) play indoor during the winter; with the greater pressure and faster pace of indoor soccer, the idea is that young players will improve their skills, speed up their development, and be better prepared to play in Major League Soccer. I can find no fault with Conrad's logic.


Following this portion of his column, Conrad asks a cynical question that had certainly run through the mind of many an MLS fan:

What is the main goal of having MLS in place? Is it about land and money and tax write-offs, or is it about something more?


Conrad closes out with his thoughts on the draft, calling for it to end and end immediately. I agree wholeheartedly, and find Conrad's suggestions for signing college players reasonable. My thoughts on the draft continue to be that it does not force MLS clubs to build a proper development system, and the longer they wait, the longer it will be until MLS is able to completely stand on its own as a respectable and established professional football league. Delaying the inevitable is doing MLS no good, and the first step in making the clubs learn to fly is to push them out of the nest without the net of the draft to catch them.


Again, Jimmy treads no ground that hasn't been covered many, many times before. But he does present specific ideas on how to make the system better, and while deeper analysis, not to mention that annoying business a multi-million dollar investement, might poke holes in his concepts, it's nice to see someone who actually plays the game step out with radical thoughts.


I'm curious as to what the MFUSA readership makes of Conrad's vision of the future, so don't hold back.


Deep Cuts: Um...Friday

Friday, November 06, 2009 | View Comments
Philadelphia Union Press Conference

If you have any reasonable level of motivation on Friday, you're a better person than I. I spent about half the time I usually do trying to find interesting links for today's edition of whatever-the-hell-this-is-called-now, but still managed to scrounge up a few.



  • MLS has a female official, and she's a former speed-skating Canadian. Seems weird, especially since I wasn't aware that MLS had a female official, but maybe that just proves the point that it doesn't matter. Besides, if she works for MLS, she has to be terrible.


  • An "on this day in history" note: On November 6, 1869, Rutgers and Princeton played the first ever intercollegiate football game in the United States. The sport they were playing was probably a bit soccer and a bit rugby, since they didn't yet seem to know what exactly the rules were back then. The English FA had only codified the first set of established laws of the game (which were still not universally accepted) in 1863, and the Yanks, as usual, did their own thing. The game between Rutgers and Princeton surely looked more like soccer than it did American football, but it doesn't really matter; intercollegiate "football" turned more towards rugby and then diverged further with the rules largly drawn up by Walter Camp in the late 19th century. It's impossible to know where the US would be as a soccer nation if the rules adopted were those of association football instead, but I'm pretty sure we wouldn't be worried about soccer "catching on".



Deep Cuts, also known as Shallow Scratches, appears as daily as is possible and brings together stories relating to American Soccer from around the web. If you have a link for Shallow Scratches/Deep Cuts, feel free to email it to matchfitusa@gmail.com.


Deep Cuts: Assuming Roles

Tuesday, October 06, 2009 | View Comments

The city of Fort Mill, South Carolina, a suburb of Charlotte, is considering whether or not to extend their lease with a minor league baseball team. Jerry Reese, Charlotte real estate lawyer, desperate to keep the team in Fort Mill so that they won't pursue a stadium in an uptown Charlotte location, is proposing to build a new facility in Fort Mill.

By this point, I'm sure you're wondering what any of this has to do with soccer, and so I'll explain; included in Reese's proposal for a new facility is a note that he hopes to convert the team's current home into a Major League Soccer stadium.

While I have no idea if Charlotte might ever get an MLS team, or if this Fort Mill plan actually has any chance of happening, I find the "news" interesting for a few reasons. First, it's an indication that professional soccer, and MLS in particular, are being thought of as worthwhile target for these type of proposals; Fort Mill isn't exactly, well, Charlotte itself, but there's something to be said for the thought even occurring to Reese. Second, MLS continues to attract interest from cities around the country (and Canada for that matter); this isn't an expansion bid, which would require an ownership group and significant investment, but it does show that soccer is on the minds of powerful people.

  • Our good buddy Jack Warner is making waves again, this time bad-mouthing England's World Cup bid. Excuse me, and many others, for seeing Warner's outburst as a not-so-subtle call for "donations" to his personal bank account. Is that an unfair assessment? Not considering Warner's track record. Still, a small part of me would like to hope that Warner is tearing down England's bid because he wants to push the US one, something I can definitely get behind. Maybe the ends don't justify the means, but I just want the World Cup back in the US so badly...


  • The NCAA site has a nice piece on the history of college soccer in St. Louis, usually viewed as the first and most significant American hotbeds of the sport. It's one of the reasons the city continues to gets mentioned as a place that MLS should expand to; whether or not that passion for youth and college soccer carries over to the professional game is the question. Conventional wisdom has St. Louis getting into MLS eventually, and the area may have a USL team in the near future (pending the resolution of the USL mess).


  • Speaking of the USL mess, the drama continues, with the Team Owners Association members meeting with USL officials and US Soccer in New York; Dave Clark at Sounder at Heart has an excellent piece on the situation and how it might shake out. I've never been a proponent of the "farm system" model as it's usually been proposed (including in this space by guest poster Vnice), but I may be open to a second/third division setup that allows MLS teams to place their reserve squads in those leagues. Dave also mentions the X-factor in all of this, the business interest that is MLS/SUM. What role they have to play will be interesting to see.


Deep Cuts: More From the Smart Kids

Thursday, October 01, 2009 | View Comments
President Obama plays with light saber during Olympic event at White House

Give it up for the Ivy League, pumping out quality articles American soccer; just yesterday, I linked to a story from a Princeton student, who related his experiences during the Summer of Soccer. Now, a Harvard writer weighs in with the first in a series of pieces on college soccer's place in the greater American soccer environment.

The writer sees the influence of the college game waning, and points to the American U-20 teams and it's makeup as an example. For many ardent soccer fans, the movement towards more professionals at that level is a good thing, and something we believe will ultimately benefit our professional league and our senior national team (something with the writer admits is probably true); the marginalization of college soccer, and the disappointment of many that it's happening, is a dividing line in the community that while unlikely to cause any debilitating splits, does color our relationships. There doesn't seem to much middle ground; either you love college soccer and see it as an important part of the American game, or you dismiss it out of hand as an impediment to the development of better players.

  • More work from the college kids, and this time it's an opinion piece on why President Obama should be focusing his attention on securing the World Cup in 2018 or 2022 rather than a Chicago Olympics in 2016. I agree completely, though I fully admit it's for selfish reasons, and I'm not really convinced that the President's push for the Olympics precludes the US from getting another World Cup, or really has any bearing on the decision of FIFA. If it is an either/or proposition, I would obviously come down on the side of soccer; a nationwide event of the World Cup's caliber, and for all of the reasons the writer mentions, would ultimately bring more than the one-city, scorched-earth nature of the Olympics. But hey, I'm a sports nut, so I say bring them both on.


  • The growing trend of American club ownership in Europe may not be extending its reach to Italy after all; Texas tycoon Timothy Barton's bid to buy Serie A club Bari has hit a snag, despite earlier reports that it was all but done. I'm not overly concerned about club ownership, generally, though I would be lying if I said I didn't hope that an American owner would lead to more European opportunities for our players. "A" doesn't necessarily lead to "B", however, so the collapse of Barton's Bari bid is more notable because Americans have yet to dip their toes into European waters outside of England to this point.


Deep Cuts appears daily and is an attempt to bring you soccer news and commentary from off the beaten path or of particular interest to American soccer fans. If you come across something you think would make a good Deep Cut, please send it along to matchfitusa@gmail.com.


Loftus Versfeld Stadium

A novel "mortgage" system, one in which fans can buy their own piece of stadium real estate (their seats) over the course of a protracted term, just as they would a condominium, could change the way professional sports teams approach stadium financing. The program allows purchasers to avoid pesky ticket price raises by locking in their annual payments, provides needed financing for stadium projects, and guarantees the buyer ownership of his or her seat no matter the stadium or if the team relocated.

A Wall Street Journal (not that deep, I know, but this is incredibly interesting) piece outlines the concept; while it is only currently being utilized by American universities hoping to expand their college football stadiums, the story suggests that Tottenham Hotspur, a club desperately looking for financing options as they look to build a replacement for White Hart Lane, might be the first professional team to enact it.

The largest problem with selling seats in this manner for professional teams looking to finance building projects is sales; while the long term investment for passionate fans might make sense, it could be difficult to sell some or most of the most expensive seats. For that reason, the concept would be a pipe dream for American soccer clubs looking for alternative financing sources to build a stadium. The game, and the leagues involved, simply don't have the profile and demand for tickets that could make the "seats as condos" idea work.

  • Vancouver Whitecaps President Bob Lenarduzzi spoke during a fund-raiser for the University of Victoria yesterday, and in a preview of his speech from the Times-Colonist he touched on several interesting topics. Among them was the belief that college soccer in Canada has a role to play in the development of professional players, the commitment of the Whitecaps to starting a new USL-1 club in Victoria once the club moves to MLS, and the frustration over the sticky stadium situation that the club currently faces. Lenarduzzi's statements on the stadium don't sound too good, and he put the lack of movement squarely on the shoulders of the local government.


  • FIFA's top medical man wants referees and coaches to step up efforts to punish violent play, and says career-ending injuries have been on the rise over the past two years. With the stakes such as they are, Michel D'Hooghe believes coaches may be complicit in some of the horrific tackles that take place on the pitch. D'Hooghe is calling for a strict application of the rules, which would mean a spike in red cards given to players who tackle from behind or use their elbows illegally. The rules are the rules, and should be applied as their written, though the practical matter is that referees are hesitant to hand out ejection, especially early in matches. If D'Hooghe did get his way, the global soccer community would be forced to go through a period of painful adjustment (not to mention controversy and anger), but would certainly come out better for it on the other side.


  • The A-League, the Australian analog for Major League Soccer with its salary cap, Marquee Player rule and franchise system, is pulling back on plans to expand. Economic factors have delayed a Sydney ownership group's hopes to start a second club in that city, and the league will remain at ten teams for at least one more season. The A-League fascinates me because of its similarities to MLS, though the differences between the two leagues and the two countries in question are significant. Still, if MLS is able to continue expanding through the worst economy in recent memory while other leagues are holding, they must be doing something right. Now if MLS would just follow the Aussies' lead and completely exempt DP player salaries from the cap...


Deep Cuts appears daily and is an attempt to bring you soccer links from off the beaten path or of particular interest. If you come across something you think would make a good Deep Cut, please send it along to matchfitusa@gmail.com.


Len Oliver, Peter Collins, Nicholas Kropfelder, Alex Ely, Alex Yannis, Colin Jose, Harry Keough, Booby Smith, Gene Olaff, George Brown, Joy Fawcett, Jeff Agoos, Chico Chacurian, Walter Bahr

The fate of the National Soccer Hall of Fame, an institution that marks its thirtieth anniversary this month, is just a bit up in the air. Located in Oneonta, NY, the Hall recently inducted players Jeff Agoos and Joy Fawcett; unfortunately, the museum itself has been closed to the public in light of budgetary concerns. Perhaps those same budgetary concerns are why so many of the links on the Hall's website are dead ends (*UPDATE* The links that were dead this morning are working now; thanks to Jack in the comments for the heads up).

An unfortunate set of circumstances, and one that may lead to the Hall of Fame being relocated. Most American soccer fans probably wouldn't be averse to a move for the Hall, but that doesn't hold true for one Oneonta city historian. He takes us down memory lane with a piece on how the Hall of Fame came to be back in 1979.

  • College soccer certainly has its detractors, especially among the pro-focused majority of American fans. The rule quirks, unlimited substitutions, and physical style turn off many who would prefer the game in the US rely more on club-run academies than scholastically-based competition. College soccer also has defenders though, and one West Virginia Mountaineer wants you to ignore the soccer snobs and enjoy the game for what it is at the university level. It seems the Mountaineers are, with 3,000 fans showing up for the soccer team's home opener.

  • I suppose that it's nice that someone in northern Idaho felt the need to defend soccer against the American version of football, though I think the comparison is unnecessary. There's enough room for both sports here, and there's really no need to get into which is "tougher". One of these days, Americans en masse will wake up to just how great the beautiful game really is, and these type of pieces will thankfully disappear. I wish they would, especially with the rampant homophobia present in this one. Ugh.



MEX SOC DAVIES

Charlie Davies is on fire. He's a young American striker who can't stop scoring; not only was he one of the lone bright spots for the USMNT in Mexico City on Wednesday, he also scored two second half goals against French Ligue 1 champions Bordeaux for his new club Sochaux on Saturday. Along with another young American striker, Jozy Altidore, Davies is a promising, exciting, potential-filled player who's career arc is headed sharply upward.

Meanwhile, Davies' countryman Freddy Adu find himself in soccer purgatory. Techincally a Benfica player, Adu does not figure in the Portuguese club's plan, and is desperately hunting down a loan deal elsewhere in Europe. Rumored links to clubs in Denmark and Holland in the last few weeks are promising, but have yet to come to ultimate fruition. Without a loan, Adu may spend another year in Europe not playing, a terrible circumstance for a young player in dire need of experience.

Two players, two paths, two spotlights; while Davies has seemingly come out of nowhere (for all but the most in-tune USMNT fans), Adu has been heralded as the "next big thing" since his adolescent years. Adu jumped into the professional game at an early age, while Davies worked his way through the typical American player path of college-to-pro. Turning down an MLS contract to head overseas to Sweden, Davies has steadily worked his way up the ladder to become the American starlet of 2009, while Adu has faded into the background, becoming a peripheral player for both club and country.

Davies' story is refreshing, and his success encouraging, mostly because he represents the typical American story; his emergence stands in direct contrast to the over-hyped nature of Adu's lack of impact, one that has seemingly turned off many in the American soccer community who bought into Freddy's "savior" potential.

Perhaps Davies has risen up the ranks thanks in part to the lack of attention. The weight places on Adu's shoulder was not only unfair, it may be been cripplingly detrimental to his development. When a young player is given the type of attention that Adu received at at a young age, it's often difficult for them to keep up the motivation needed to improve. It's human nature; not everyone is equipped to deal with premature stardom properly, and Adu's exit from both DC United and MLS indicate that he may not have understood the sacrifice needed to turn himself into the soccer messiah that everyone thought he could be.

Now Adu finds himself stagnating, be it though his own hubris or a simple matter of circumstance. Time has not run out on him necessarily, but the completing the road to redemption and summarily reversing his career arc are a long way off.

Davies has no such pressure. While a star both at high school in New Hampshire and in college at Boston College, Davies received none of the widespread media attention that Adu attracted. The label "phenom" never came into play with Davies, and his path from amateur to professional soccer took a more mundane route. Heading to Sweden after college seemed an odd choice considering that Davies would have been a high MLS draft pick and a sure bet for a Generation Adidas scholarship; but it set the stage for the young American to turn heads on the continent that might not have otherwise taken notice had he played professionally in the United States. Able to contribute immediately in the second-tier European league that is Sweden's Allsvenskan, Charlie improved dramatically as a player. When given the opportunity to showcase himself on the international stage of the Confederations Cup, Davies seized it completely, adding to his resume. His effort paid off on the club level when Hammarby sold him to Ligue 1 side Sochaux, a step up for him and an indication of his overall growth as a player.

Since his transfer, Davies has scored once in World Cup qualifying for his country, and twice for his new club in France. "Hot" doesn't begin to describe his form.

Rarely will a player, massive potential or not, be forced to endure (or be lucky enough to receive) the type of attention that Freddy Adu did as a youth. Whether Adu would have come to this point in his career without that attention is impossible to know. But it's worth asking; would Adu have become a better player had the spotlight not fallen on him at such a young age?

The system for player development as it currently existe in the United States means that most will finally themselves on the Charlie Davies path. From youth, to college, to professional, they chip away, constantly working to get better, hoping to find themselves fulfilling their potential in their early-twenties. Two such players, Anton Peterlin and Cody Arnaux, are doing just that, and are now signed to contracts with a high-profile English club in Everton. Add college star Marcus Tracy, whose situation more closely parallels Davies' at this point in his career, and examples pile up. Anonymous names not too long ago, they are now seen as possible future players for their country; if they had been pegged as sure things at fourteen, would they have made the same leap?

Identifying promising talent in a country of 300 million will never be an easy task. The college system and MLS draft serve as stop-gap approaches to filling professional rosters in the United States and Canada because the work of scouting and development is so daunting and expensive. To damn that system because it doesn't fit the world standard is understandable, and the future still probably lies with overhauling the process. But for now, while prodigies and phenoms are chewed up and spit out by the media and hype machine, it seems clear that sometimes the status quo can produce quality players. Anonymity is a powerful motivator.

Case in point, Charlie Davies.


    KKTC Bahis Siteleri, Online Bahis

    Legal


    Privacy Policy